The complete guide to REITs
A REIT is a bargain struck with the tax code: escape corporate tax, and in exchange accept rules about what you own, how you earn, who owns you, and how much cash you must hand over every year. Everything distinctive about REIT analysis follows from that bargain.
What a REIT actually is
A real estate investment trust is a company that owns income-producing property, or lends against it, and has elected a special tax status under sections 856 to 860 of the US Internal Revenue Code. The election has one enormous benefit and a long list of conditions attached.
The benefit is the removal of one layer of tax. A normal corporation earns profit, pays corporate income tax on it, and then hands the remainder to shareholders who pay tax again. A REIT deducts the dividends it pays from its own taxable income, so income that gets distributed is taxed once, in the shareholder's hands.
That 21% gap, compounded across decades, is the entire reason the structure exists. It is also why the rules around it are so restrictive: Congress wanted the benefit to reach passive property income and nothing else.
Everything that makes REIT analysis feel foreign comes from this trade. The mandatory payout means the company retains almost no cash, so it must return to the capital markets to grow. The heavy depreciation on buildings makes reported net income close to useless. And because rent is contracted years ahead, the interesting information sits in lease schedules rather than in the income statement.
How the law got here
Knowing the legislative history isn't trivia. Each of these changes created a structural feature you'll meet in filings, and several of them explain why one REIT can do something a competitor cannot.
The rulebook a REIT lives under
Four families of tests decide whether a company keeps its REIT status: how it is organised, what it owns, where its income comes from, and how much it distributes. Miss one badly and the company is taxed as a normal corporation, with a four-year lockout before it can elect again. Cure provisions exist for good-faith failures, and they come with penalty taxes.
What counts as good rent
The 75% income test sounds simple until you look at what disqualifies rent. These rules shape real commercial behaviour, and they are the reason certain REITs own subsidiaries that pay full corporate tax on purpose.
How REIT income gets taxed in your hands
A REIT dividend is not one thing. Every January the company publishes a table breaking the prior year's distributions into components, each taxed differently. Until that table arrives, nobody knows the exact split, including the company.
If you are not a US taxpayer
Ordinary REIT dividends paid to non-residents carry 30% US withholding by default. Treaties often cut that, commonly to 15% for small holders, but many treaties specifically deny REITs the low rate reserved for direct corporate investment. Capital gain distributions attributable to US property gains fall under FIRPTA and are treated as effectively connected income, with an exception for holders of 10% or less in a regularly traded REIT.
Types, wrappers and structures
Equity REITs
Mortgage REITs
Hybrid
Listed, non-traded, private
Internal versus external management
An internally managed REIT employs its own staff, and G&A shows up as a line in the income statement. An externally managed REIT pays an adviser a fee, usually on gross assets, sometimes with an incentive fee on top. The gross-asset fee is the problem: it pays the manager more for buying more, using more debt, whether or not the deals help shareholders. External management can work well when the manager has scale and skin in the game, and it is a durable conflict when they don't.
UPREIT, OP units and the 721 exchange
Most large US REITs are umbrella partnership REITs. The listed company is the general partner of an operating partnership, and the buildings sit in that partnership. A property owner can contribute a building to the OP in exchange for OP units under Section 721, deferring capital gains and depreciation recapture until those units are converted or the property is sold. It's a currency the REIT can pay in without touching cash or issuing shares directly.
Where the money actually comes from
Below the tax wrapper is a fairly simple business: collect rent, pay the cost of running the building, and keep the difference. That difference is net operating income, and it is the atom of real estate analysis.
NOI converts to value through the cap rate, which behaves like a yield. Divide NOI by the cap rate to get value, and note what happens when the cap rate moves on a levered balance sheet.
An 8% fall in property value became a 14% fall in equity value, on debt of only 45% of assets. Nothing happened to the rent. This is why leverage discipline and cap rate assumptions carry so much weight in REIT valuation, and why NAV estimates should always be shown as a range.
Lease structures, and why they change everything
The three growth engines
Internal growth
External growth
Financial engineering
FFO, and the problem it solves
GAAP requires buildings to be depreciated over 27.5 to 39 years, as if a well-maintained warehouse were being consumed like a machine tool. Sometimes that's true. Often the building is worth more after ten years than it cost. Nareit created FFO in 1991 to strip that distortion out, and restated the definition in November 2018.
Net income of $60M implies a company barely breaking even. FFO of $215M reflects what the portfolio actually produced. The $25M gain was removed because selling a building once is not a repeatable business.
Nareit FFO versus Core FFO
Nearly every REIT also reports Core FFO, Normalised FFO, or Operating FFO, adding back things it considers one-off: debt extinguishment costs, transaction expenses, severance, litigation. Some of those adjustments are fair. A company that reports "one-off" costs every quarter for five years is describing its cost structure, not an anomaly. Read the reconciliation, and keep a running tally of how often the same adjustment reappears.
AFFO — the number the dividend is actually paid from
Same FFO, and the office REIT has 40% less cash available for distribution. On a $150M dividend, one is comfortably covered at a 75% payout and the other is paying out 125% of what it earns. A screen ranking these two on P/FFO would show them as equally priced.
The straight-line rent adjustment, explained
GAAP makes a landlord recognise rent evenly across a lease term, even when the contract steps up over time. In year one of a ten-year lease with 3% annual bumps, reported revenue exceeds cash collected, and the difference sits on the balance sheet as a straight-line rent receivable. AFFO removes it. If that receivable is growing fast relative to revenue, a meaningful part of reported growth is an accrual rather than money in the bank.
The balance sheet is half the analysis
A REIT retains at most 10% of taxable income. It funds everything else with debt and new equity, which makes it a permanent participant in capital markets and unusually exposed to their mood. Two REITs with identical buildings can deliver completely different shareholder outcomes based on how they financed them.
Net debt / EBITDAre
Fixed charge coverage
Maturity ladder
Secured versus unsecured
The analyst dashboard
Every number below appears in a quarterly supplemental package. Build the table once for any REIT you own and update it each quarter, and you'll see problems developing long before they reach a press release.
Seven ways to value a REIT, and when each one lies
Sector by sector — the differences that matter
Property type sets the rules of the game: how long the cash flow is contracted for, how much capital it takes to keep it, and what a normal payout ratio looks like. A 7% yield in gaming and a 7% yield in office describe two completely different situations.
Mortgage REITs are not equity REITs
A mortgage REIT buys mortgages or mortgage-backed securities, funds them mostly with short-term repurchase agreements, and keeps the spread. There are no buildings, no tenants, and no leases. FFO, AFFO, occupancy, and same-store NOI are all irrelevant here, and applying them is the most common analytical error in the sector.
How to actually judge one
- Economic return, not dividend yield. Add the change in book value per share to dividends paid, divide by opening book value. A 14% dividend alongside a 16% book value decline is a 2% loss, not income.
- Price to book, over time. mREITs are portfolios of marked securities, so book value per share is a real number. Compare the current P/B to the five-year range.
- Book value per share over a decade. Many mortgage REITs have paid enormous dividends while book value fell for ten straight years. That is capital being returned and consumed, dressed as income.
- The hedge book. Read the interest rate sensitivity table in Item 7A. It tells you what management thinks a 100bp move does to book value, using their own assumptions.
A dividend safety framework that works
REIT dividend cuts are usually visible two to six quarters ahead if you're looking at the right things. Run these six checks in order, and stop at the first one that fails.
Eight red flags worth walking away from
The 12-step REIT workflow
This is the order to work in. Steps 2 and 3 are where most of the value is, and they're the ones most people skip.
REITs outside the United States
More than forty countries now run a REIT-style regime. The economics rhyme everywhere: no tax at the entity level in exchange for a mandatory payout. The details differ enough to change your after-tax return.
What REITs do in a portfolio
Income with contractual growth
Partial inflation protection
Diversification that isn't absolute
Tax placement matters
One warning worth repeating: sector selection dominates. The dispersion between the best and worst REIT property sectors in a given year routinely exceeds 40 percentage points, which is far larger than the dispersion between companies within a sector. Deciding you want industrial exposure is a bigger decision than which industrial REIT you buy.